
Santorum wins three primaries in one night: Colorado, Minnesota and Missouri. Just when I thought he was out, he wins three in a row. I ordered his book, It Takes A Family (a clear reference to Hillary's It Takes a Village).
Many people want to throw their kids upon the village, and have them raise them. Well, really, only families can raise kids. What constitutes a family? We are about to have a huge debate, if Santorum can win the nomination.
What we'll see is the resurgence of a Catholic framework that has been worked out over a two thousand year period, aligned up against the flimsy multicultural Marxism of the left. I don't know if Santorum can continue his momentum, but if he does he will entirely change the conversation.
The Gingrich moment seems to have petered out, floundering on the rock of his ex-wives' allegations, and his own rhetorical violence. Santorum on the other hand has solidity on his side, and an unwavering commitment to Catholic ideals.
This race just keeps getting more interesting. Personally I had hoped that Romney would pull ahead so we could begin to work with him. He's goodlooking, and he has some business sense. But Romney has been for abortion, and for other things (Romneycare) that are anathema to many on the right.
I think almost all the people on the left will be bitterly angry if Santorum wins the nomination. They went to all the trouble of knocking out Pawlenty, Bachman, Cain, Gingrich, Huntsman, and tried in vain over and over to make sure that Romney was the alternative. The right meanwhile kept trying to get behind different candidates. Anyone BUT Romney. Santorum has somehow survived and somehow has traction finally.
The only thing I know that he's said is in reaction to a question from a college student in New Hampshire. She asked, why are you against two men in love, and willing to marry? He asked Socratically, why not three men in a tub, rub a dub dub? I heard this second-hand, and need to verify that's exactly how it went, but I think that's what he said. I should track this down!
I did find it funny that he put it into the framework of a nursery rhyme. It's the first reference to any kind of poetry in the debates.
One thing the Catholics have worked out over the last thousand years are a set of clear definitions. From St. Thomas Aquinas forwards, they have worked on the notion of beauty which they define as coherence and complexity, and on the notion of ethics, down to whether or not the fingernails will grow in the afterlife (I can't remember if they will or not). There is something to be said for Catholic unity, and discipline, and the powerful intellectual life they've created through the monastery system and their willingness to work on even the most arcane questions in order to create firm definitions.
If Santorum wins, we'll see the logic the Catholics have worked out over the last thousand years and more come into play against the often crazy and meandering logic of the left that has been worked out in the humanistic (man is the measure of all things) secularizing universities (which have in essence nothing but desire holding them together). The OWS movement was the epitome of this, with Zizek arguing for having sex with animals along with socialism, as somehow one leading to the other. Against that, three men in a tub sounds like orthodoxy. I had to hold my head as I listened to Zizek's logic befor ethe OWS crowd, held together merely by desire, rather than by any sense of what's reasonable or healthy for animals and people.
I am now hoping this Santorum-Obama debate will take place, as old questions that have been silenced over the last twenty years will come back into play. What is a family? What is beauty? What is a community? I think many Lutherans and other evangelicals will be willing to close ranks with the Catholic Santorum, as they really can't quite with either Gingrich (whose personal life is a monumental disaster) or with Romney, who is from such a strange tradition that most of us aren't even familiar with it, or with their ideas that Christ lived with Native Americans after Gethsemane, for instance. Mormons apparently believe you get your own universe after you die. This may not matter in politics, but it is very strange for most of us who believe there is just one God, and we're not it. Also, in terms of sheer numbers, the Catholics, even after all their problems, still have an enormous army at their command, while the Mormons -- not so much. We need to win more than Utah if we're going to win the White House. Can Santorum pull it off?
He will face very stiff resistance in a way that Romney, who is a much less defined entity (Romney is a gas, while Gingrich is a liquid, and Santorum a solid). At the very least Santorum will provide definitions, or definition, to the race. I for one would like that. I want something that is like a rock: solid. The church is that, at least as it was originally defined (before it started to become a gas in the 60s).